New York City’s Merchant’s House is Insanely Haunted

New York City’s Merchant’s House is Insanely Haunted

The Merchant’s House

The Merchant’s House, erected in 1832, is New York City’s only surviving, fully intact 19th Century family home and one of its most haunted places. Built by Joseph Brewster in Manhattan’s Bowery, the home was soon sold to Seabury Tredwell, a rich merchant. The Tredwell’s were to live within the house for many years with Gertrude, Seabury’s youngest daughter, remaining within the home until her death in 1933. She was able to keep the home intact, in great shape and safe from demolition, despite financial pressures. In 1936 a cousin who had purchased the property restored and opened the home as a museum that continues to function and offers a fascinating glimpse into New York’s past to visitors today.

New York City Merchant House Haunted.
The exterior of the historic and haunted Merchant’s House in New York City.

Ghosts of New York’s Merchant’s House

Since opening to the public, many ghost stories and accounts of paranormal experiences within the Merchant’s House have circulated. It is widely believed that New York’s Merchant’s House is one of the most haunted places in the city continuing to function as a home to the Tredwells since their deaths.

Entry way to Merchant House in New York City.
Front entrance to the haunted Merchant’s House in New York City.

Strange phenomena such as unexplainable smells, sudden temperature drops, disembodied voices, footsteps coming from empty rooms and the sounds coming from a piano that does not work have been reported for many years. There have also been many instances of individuals sighting apparitions. The most commonly seen ghost is believed to be the Tredwell’s youngest daughter, Gertrude. Gertrude was born inside the Merchant’s House in 1840 and lived out her entire 93 years there, being the last remaining Tredwell to occupy the Merchant’s House. Multiple witnesses have reportedly seen an elderly lady throughout the home and sometimes a younger version of the same woman, believed to be Gertrude. She is most commonly seen near the bedroom she passed away in or near the front door.

Merchant House bedroom.
Inside one of the Merchant’s House’s upstairs bedrooms.

Seabury Tredwell is also rumored to haunt the Merchant’s House. Many staff and visitors have reported to feel a presence around them in the upstairs bedrooms. Some visitors have even had encounters with Seabury. One group of people claimed that an elderly man asked them to leave and blocked their entry to the upstairs study. As they went to leave the property they caught a glimpse of Seabury Tredwell’s portrait downstairs and recognized him as the man they had just interacted with.

Haunted study in Merchant House.
Study inside of the Merchant’s House where Seabury Tredwell’s ghost has been sighted.

The Merchant’s Home’s attic, which was the former maid quarters, has also been described as a paranormal hotspot. Full body apparitions in period clothing have been seen here. During my own visit, I caught banging noises on camera whilst in the room, which were not audible to me at the time of filming.

Merchant House Maid bedroom.
Maid quarters in the attic of New York City’s Merchant’s House.

The upstairs bedrooms are another active location, with many hearing the sound of children’s footsteps running up and down the nearby hallways when no one is around. Within the bedrooms, made-up beds have been crumpled without explanation and light anomalies have been caught on camera. Others have claimed to have seen and even conversed with Samuel Tredwell, the family’s youngest son. One woman claimed to speak with his spirit after smelling an overpowering smell of mothballs.

Dining room of Merchant House.
The dining room area of the Merchant’s House where paranormal activity has been documented.

Other paranormal reports include laid tables being messed up, a chandelier that mysteriously swayed for 45 minutes without explanation, creaking floorboards in empty rooms and bells ringing on their own accord. Shaking furniture and captured EVP’s within the kitchen have also been reported. One paranormal investigator allegedly asked ‘what was your role here?’ Whilst in the kitchen and received a recorded response of ‘a servant.’

Inside the haunted Merchant House.
Bell inside Merchant’s House that has been known to ring on its own accord.

Visiting the Haunted Merchant’s House

Is New York City’s Merchant’s House really as haunted as all of these stories suggest? Pay it a visit and find out for yourself!

Sofa in Merchant House.
Lounge area inside the haunted Merchant’s House in New York City.

The home still operates as a museum today and candle light ghost tours run during October. I visited during the week and had the house to myself for much of my visit. Guided tours are available, yet the self-guided tour is also very comprehensive and allows you to explore the grounds at your own pace. Staff will provide you with a binder of information that leads you around the house, they have both a general history and a paranormal occurrences book available from the office.

Exterior street view of Merchant House in New York City.
Exterior of the Merchant’s House in New York City. Lucky to have survived while many other buildings around it were demolished.

The house has been incredibly restored and contains many artifacts and furniture which were original to the Tredwell family. Visits are a fascinating glimpse of what life would have looked like in 19th Century New York City.

Haunted bedrooms inside Merchant House.
Exploring the haunted Merchant House bedrooms.

If you enjoyed this blog and are looking for other spooky places in New York City to visit, check out my pick for its 10 most haunted places.

Thanks for reading!


Amy's Crypt Signature

About Amy

Amy is a world traveller and explorer of creepy locations. She has visited some of the most famously haunted places around the world in search of evidence of the paranormal. Follow Amy's Journey:

Comments (6)

  • Pam

    Posted by Pam on April 11, 2020

    I’d add the Morris Jumel mansion to the list to make it 11. Check out the Belasco Theater as well to make it a dangerous dozen. Heck, you could list the Haunted Hundred in the 5 boroughs and not come close to the end of it. Nice job, Amy!


      Posted by Amy on April 14, 2020

      Thanks for the suggestions, Pam! I will need to look these places up.

  • Pam

    Posted by Pam on April 11, 2020

    Gosh, sorry — thought I was leaving a comment on your list of Ten Most Haunted NYC spots. Merchant’s House is certainly one of them. Thanks for this post and your video. Very spooky!


      Posted by Amy on April 14, 2020

      You are totally fine! I truly appreciate your input and you reading!


    Posted by KATHRYN on October 19, 2020

    Thought it was absolutely amazing


      Posted by Amy on October 20, 2020

      Thanks for reading, Kathryn. Glad you enjoyed it.

Leave a Reply